24 comments

• Sameera SatijaLeave aside this particular issue for a moment and look around!! Do you think we are getting the basic infrastucture in return of the amount of taxes you pay? If your ans in NO then this protest is justified as it is to demand answerability
• Vivek VermaWhy SJ why? You could have blurred the name of the kid Hide
• Saurabh JShalini Makhija Venugopal Gurumoorthy Mathrubootham why you angry? Did I do something wrong?
• Balasubramanian PalaniveluRavi is the last name(Father's name) Hide
• Rama Lakshmi DhavalaThis is one highly embarrassing function for girls across TN and AP/Telangana. Many families have done away with it but a sizeable amount still indulge in broadcasting by celebrating as a function. Hide
• Shiuli SubayaRites of passage rituals are so important for younger people especially and Tamil Nadu still honours many of these in traditional ways. Hide
• Rekha Patil ReddyBelieve it or not, this is happening in London too . Hide
• Shiuli SubayaWhat’s with all the shame Hide
• Tanushree RoyDisgusting Hide
• Balagopal RavibalanIt is common to celebrate menarche in many cultures - as a symbol of fertility. It usually has a priest involved and then a grand feast. The choice of words here is unfortunate. The hypocrisy however is in the fact that from the next time onewards the same girl will be branded "impure" when the same thing happens. If you wanna know the scale of this "celebration" check out this video from a Tamil movie https://youtu.be/Aothm1rjxU0?si=p5ijrQ47vB-Mzw0e Hide
• Gautam GhaiJust the word seems awkward, not the occasion or celebration. Rather than embarrassing, I think it removes the stigma or shame associated. Hide
• Swapna SitaramanI had nightmares about this event in my life. My parents told me about it and I showed no interst in such a function. In such cases, i feel the child should be asked. I would have hated my parents if they went ahead with it without my approval Hide
• Millie KhannaSorry, what's wrong or angering? Except for the choice of English words which must come from non native speakers of English. If you can do a mundan for a boy, why not this? If done right, it would remove period shaming. Maybe criticise the shaming around periods and especially in TN of calling them impure and instead celebrate it as detoxification or renewal of a cycle, a fresh start. Nitpicking on a banner shan't help you look woke. Hide
• Sherebanu FroshI should do something. Bar mitzvah, misaq. Maybe taking something from all these traditions. Thanks for the idea! (My poor kids) Hide
• Vivek VermaVivek Verma  · 2yWhy SJ why? You could have blurred the name of the kidLikeReplyHide
• Saurabh JSaurabh J  · 2yShalini Makhija Venugopal Gurumoorthy Mathrubootham why you angry? Did I do something wrong?LikeReply
• Balasubramanian PalaniveluBalasubramanian Palanivelu  · 2y  · by authorRavi is the last name(Father's name)ReplyHide
• Rama Lakshmi DhavalaRama Lakshmi Dhavala  · 2y  · by authorThis is one highly embarrassing function for girls across TN and AP/Telangana. Many families have done away with it but a sizeable amount still indulge in broadcasting by celebrating as a function.ReplyHideEdited
• Shiuli SubayaShiuli Subaya  · 2yRites of passage rituals are so important for younger people especially and Tamil Nadu still honours many of these in traditional ways.LikeReplyHide
• Rekha Patil ReddyRekha Patil Reddy  · 2y  · by authorBelieve it or not, this is happening in London too .ReplyHide
• Shiuli SubayaShiuli Subaya  · 2yWhat’s with all the shameLikeReplyHide
• Tanushree RoyTanushree Roy  · 2yDisgustingLikeReplyHide
• Balagopal RavibalanBalagopal Ravibalan  · 2yIt is common to celebrate menarche in many cultures - as a symbol of fertility. It usually has a priest involved and then a grand feast. The choice of words here is unfortunate.The hypocrisy however is in the fact that from the next time onewards the same girl will be branded "impure" when the same thing happens.If you wanna know the scale of this "celebration" check out this video from a Tamil movie https://youtu.be/Aothm1rjxU0?si=p5ijrQ47vB-Mzw0eLikeReplyHideEdited
• Gautam GhaiGautam Ghai  · 2yJust the word seems awkward, not the occasion or celebration. Rather than embarrassing, I think it removes the stigma or shame associated.LikeReplyHide